Saatva vs Casper

My Top 10 Mattresses Sold Online

These are my 10 favorites of the 60+ mattresses we've reviewed.

NOTE: We earn from qualifying purchases made via Amazon Associates and other affiliate programs. Learn more.

  • #1 SAATVA: 4.9/5

    Saatva is a highly-rated luxury innerspring mattress that costs far less than comparable store brands.

    Buy This One If: you are shopping for a premium innerspring or hybrid mattress like a Simmons Beautyrest, Kingsdown Ashley, Sterns & Foster Ashley or Serta iSeries.

    Comfort Choices: Soft, Med Firm, Firm

    • Highest-rated mattress on our site
    • Outstanding pressure relief
    • 120-night in-home trial
    • Free White Glove Delivery & Removal
    • Excellent value

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Saatva Online

  • #2 LEESA: 4.6/5

    Leesa is the best one-size-fits-all memory foam mattress sold online. Sleeps noticeably better than Casper - for less money.

    Buy This One If: you want a great-sleeping, supportive foam mattress for a bargain price. This one is a steal right now.

    Comfort Choices: Medium Firm

    • Unique foam construction w/ excellent support
    • Low motion transfer, great for couples.
    • Sleeps cool - no heat issues
    • 100 night in-home trial
    • Outstanding value

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Leesa Online

  • #3 PLUSHBEDS: 4.8/5

    Plushbeds Botanical Bliss is the the best-sleeping, highest-quality 100% latex mattress sold online. All-natural materials, lots of options, and a super-long warranty.

    Buy This One If: you want a true all-natural latex mattress without making compromises. This one has it all.

    Comfort Choices: Soft, Med, Med Firm, XFirm

    • Top-quality all-natural materials (organic cotton, wool, Talalay)
    • Greenguard Certified
    • Split option available
    • 100 night in-home trial
    • 25 year warranty

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit PlushBeds Online

  • #4 NECTAR: 4.6/5

    Nectar bed is a budget-friend memory foam mattress has it all: advanced foam engineering, sleeps cool, good edge support… plus an industry-first LIFETIME warranty.

    Buy This One If: you want a high-quality foam mattress with maximum wallet protection.

    Comfort Choices: Medium-Firm

    • One of the best budget foam mattresses I’ve reviewed.
    • Excellent all-round sleeping experience
    • High quality materials
    • Same price as Casper, Tuft and Needle, et al – but with a FAR better warranty.

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Nectar Online

  • #5 NEST: 4.8/5

    The Nest Alexander Hybrid bed is a super-comfy, cool-sleeping hybrid mattress that’s just about perfect for loving couples. One of the best we’ve tested.

    Buy This One If: you are half of an amorous couple - or like to move around at night.

    Comfort Choices: Plush, Medium, Luxury-Firm

    • One of the most comfortable mattresses you can buy online
    • Excellent cooling performance
    • Lifetime warranty
    • Perfect for loving couples
    • Excellent edge support

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Nest Bedding

  • #6 LEESA HYBRID: 4.7/5

    Leesa Hybrid is a luxury mattress with a great bounce & excellent support – and a really great price.

    Buy This One If: looking for medium-firm premium luxury innerspring mattress (80% of us).

    Comfort Choices: Medium-Firm

    • Excellent support, thanks to the pocketed coil layer
    • Excellent edge support
    • Very little motion transfer = great for couples
    • Bouncy feel = great for sex
    • 10-Year Warranty

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Leesa NOW

  • #7 DREAMCLOUD: 4.7/5

    Dreamcloud is a 15-inch luxury hybrid mattress with a comfy pillowtop and fine details that costs FAR less than a store-bought equivalent.

    Buy This One If: you demand the absolute best quality and prefer a slightly firmer feel.

    Comfort Choices: Medium-Firm

    • Tufted, quilted top feels super-luxurious
    • Outstanding level of support
    • Sturdy enough for heavier sleepers
    • Great choice for fidgety couples (no motion transfer)
    • Lifetime warranty and 365-night trial

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Dreamcloud NOW

  • #8 HELIX: 4.7/5

    Helix is a high-quality foam + coil mattress that is custom-fit to your unique sleeping habits and body – and your partner’s.

    Buy This One If: wants a custom-fit sleeping experience. Also for couples who differ in their needs.

    Comfort Choices: Plush, Medium, Firm

    • Unlimited customization (quiz makes it easy)
    • High-quality foam + coil construction
    • Exceptionally cool-sleeping
    • Excellent customer service
    • 10 year warranty

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Helix NOW

  • #9 PURPLE: 4.7/5

    The new Purple Hybrid Premiere mattress adds durable coil support and more comfort choices to its unique Comfort grid elastic top layer. The result is a heavenly night’s sleep.

    Buy This One If: want a mattress that adjusts its feel to your comfort needs. Truly unique.

    Comfort Choices: Soft, Medium, Firm

    • Very comfortable, with a unique soft+firm feel.
    • Almost zero motion transfer
    • Excellent edge support
    • Sleeps cool & dry
    • 10 year warranty

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Purple NOW

  • #10 LOOM & LEAF: 4.7/5

    A luxury organic foam mattress that surpasses the sleep experience of premium store brands - for far less money.

    Buy This One If: you want an organic foam mattress for half the price in stores.

    Comfort Choices: Medium-Firm, Firm

    • About as organic as a foam mattress can be
    • No new-mattress smell / off-gassing
    • Excellent support
    • Outstanding cooling performance
    • 10 year warranty

    Read our in-depth review

    Visit Loom & Leaf NOW


Other good choices: IDLE Sleep Zenhaven Amore Beds Tuft and Needle Leesa Sleep Number Amerisleep Sleepazza Casper Lull Helix Sleep Purple Metta Bed Luxi Sleep BedJet

Affiliate Disclosure

Affiliate Disclosure: I may earn a small commission (at no cost to you) if you purchase a mattress after clicking a referral link or using a coupon code on this site. That said, all content and opinions on this site are my own and are NOT affected by these payments.

This site participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

*Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of, Inc, or its affiliates.

Leave a Comment