Shopping for a comfortable mattress topper?
You've come to the right place.
A mattress topper is an affordable way of upgrading your current mattress compared to buying a new mattress.
If your mattress feels too firm, too soft, or just plain uncomfortable, the right mattress topper can help.
You can get a mattress topper to improve support, get better pressure relief for your back, shoulders, and hips, or make the bed cooler. You can also use a topper to add loft if you feel that your bed is too low.
Note, however, that a mattress topper is not a cure-all for an uncomfortable mattress. If your mattress is seriously worn out, sagging or falling apart, you are better off buying a new mattress.
But if the mattress is still in good shape but could be more comfortable, a mattress topper is the best solution.
What's In This Buying Guide?
In this in-depth buying guide, we review the top 10 mattress toppers for 2021. Our top picks cover different types of toppers, including natural latex and memory foam.
We also give you tips on how to select the best mattress topper depending on your comfort needs and the kind of mattress you have.
If you are specifically looking for mattress toppers that will reduce or prevent back pain, see our roundup of the best mattress toppers for back pain.
The 12 Best Mattress Toppers for 2023
In a hurry? Here's a quick list of our top picks plus a comparison table.
- Best Value: LINENSPA 2 Inch Gel Infused
- Best Comfort: MOLECULE AIRTEC™ MATTRESS TOPPER
- Best Pressure Point Relief: MyPillow Three-inch Mattress Bed Topper
- Best Cooling: LUCID 2-Inch Ventilated Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Best for Stomach Sleepers: Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper
- Best for Side Sleepers: Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Foam 4-inch Dual Layer
- Best Temperature Regulation: Sleep Number DUALTEMP™ INDIVIDUAL LAYER
- Best Memory Foam: Tempur-Pedic ProForm Mattress Topper
- Best Organic: Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper
- Best for Heavy Sleepers: Latex Mattress Factory 3” Medium
- Best For Back Pain: LUCID 2 Inch Zoned Gel
- Best For Softening a Firm Mattress: Amazon Basics Down-Alternative
| Topper | Size | Material | Firmness | Warr. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
LINENSPA Link goes to Amazon | Best Value | 2" | Gel memory foam | Medium | 3 years |
MOLECULE AIRTEC | Best Comfort | 3" | Memory foam | Medium-firm | 5 years |
MyPillow Link goes to Amazon | Best pressure point relief | 3" | Foam | Medium-firm | 10 years |
LUCID Link goes to Amazon | Best cooling | 2" | Gel memory foam | Soft | 3 years |
Pure Green Link goes to Amazon | Best for stomach sleepers | 2" | Natural latex | Extra-firm | 5 years |
Sleep Innovations Link goes to Amazon | Best for side sleepers | 4" | Gel memory foam | Soft | 10 years |
Sleep Number DUAL TEMP | Best temperature regulation | - | Forced Air | - | 1 year |
TEMPUR ProForm Link goes to Amazon | Best memory foam | 3" | Memory foam | Medium-firm | 10 years |
Avocado Green | Best organic | 2" | Organic latex | Soft/firm | 10 years |
Latex Mattress Factory Link goes to Amazon | Best for heavy sleepers | 3” | Natural Dunlop latex | Medium | Not specified |
Lucid zoned gel memory foam topper Link goes to Amazon | Best for back pain | 2” (3” option available) | Zoned gel memory foam | Medium soft | 3 years |
AmazonBasics down alternative topper Link goes to Amazon | Best for softening a firm mattress | Variable | Down alternative (polyester fiber) | Soft | Not specified |
1. Best Value: LINENSPA 2 Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Looking for a comfortable mattress topper at a bargain price? We recommend the LINENSPA 2″ gel memory foam topper.
It is one of the cheapest ways to rejuvenate your uncomfortable mattress.
Pros
- Good value for money.
- Gel memory foam helps with cooling.
- Soft pressure relief – ideal for firm mattresses.
Cons
- Not ideal for hot sleepers.
Our Review
If you are looking for an easy and affordable way to make your too-firm mattress more comfortable, the Linenspa 2″ gel memory foam topper is a great choice.
The topper doesn't turn your mattress into a mushy swamp. For one, it has a low 2″ profile, meaning you won't sink deep into it. Two, it has a medium comfort feel – not too soft and not too firm.
This makes Linenspa the best choice for most types of sleepers. Whether you sleep on your back or side, the memory foam topper reduces pressure points under your back, shoulders, and hips.
The Linenspa topper can also help if you have back, hip, or shoulder pain by cushioning the aching areas.
The topper is infused with a cooling gel that draws heat away from your body. This reduces the heating effect that memory foam is notorious for.
The Linenspa topper is available in all standard sizes and comes with a 3-year warranty.
Issues & Limitations
Despite having gel beads infused into the foam, the Linespa topper can still feel a bit too warm for hot sleepers.
If you are a naturally hot sleeper, we recommend the LUCID 2-Inch Ventilated Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper instead (reviewed further below).
Bottom Line
A low price doesn't always mean lower quality. So don't let the affordable price tag fool you. The Linenspa gel memory foam topper is one of the best upgrades you can make to your mattress.
2. Best Comfort: MOLECULE AIRTEC™ MATTRESS TOPPER
It's hard to find ‘the most comfortable topper,' but the Molecule AirTEC topper comes close to winning that award.
With a cooling fiber cover and a special foam core, the AirTEC topper beats most other mattress toppers in cooling, pressure relief, support, and overall comfort.
On the downside, all that comfort doesn't come cheap.
Pros
- Excellent support and pressure relief.
- Sleeps cooler than conventional memory foam toppers.
- Eco-friendly manufacturing.
- Financing available.
Cons
- Pricey.
Our Review
The Molecule topper has a three-layer design, each layer being 1″ thick.
The first layer is a special memory foam formulation the manufacturer calls MOLECULARFLO™. MOLECULARFLO memory foam has better airflow than conventional memory foam.
Even without gel and other infused cooling substances, the memory foam layer manages to stay cool.
MOLECULARFLO has the same body-hugging qualities of ordinary memory foam, which ensures pressure point relief on your shoulders, hips, and back.
The second layer is an open-cell foam the manufacturer calls AIRTEC™. The open-cell design further improves airflow, which carries excess body heat away from the mattress.
The support layer uses a type of polyfoam they call RECOVERYFLO™. It is firmer and denser than the other layers and provides compression support to keep you from sagging into the mattress.
The three layers are wrapped in a special cooling fabric cover. The cover has microfibers that carry heat away from your body. The cooling cover, combined with the air memory foam, guarantees a cool night's sleep.
The Molecule topper has a medium-firm comfort feel. It adds just enough softness to relieve pressure points but is firm enough to keep your spine properly aligned.
It's ideal for too-firm mattresses as well as too-soft mattresses with inadequate support.
Issues & Limitations
The Molecule AirTEC topper is one of the most expensive memory foam toppers in the market. If you are looking for a budget topper, this is not it.
Bottom Line
Though pricey, the Molecule AirTEC topper is worth the money. It adds more support to an unsupportive mattress, softens a too-firm mattress and provides a cooler sleeping experience for hot sleepers.
By the way, you can apply for Klarna financing if you prefer splitting your payments.
3. Best Pressure Point Relief: MyPillow Three-inch Mattress Bed Topper
The MyPillow topper has dual foam layers. The top layer is designed specifically for superior pressure point relief.
If you often wake up with a sore back, hips, or shoulder, the MyPillow topper will help.
Pros
- Excellent pressure relief.
- Good support.
- Good for back pain and other body aches.
- 10-year warranty.
Cons
- Pricey.
- Not ideal for hot sleepers.
Our Review
Unlike most foam toppers that are designed to make your bed softer, the MyPillow topper focuses on both pressure relief and support.
The dual-layer design results in a medium-firm comfort feel that feels great for different types of sleepers.
The top layer is softer and wraps around your pressure points. This is especially helpful if you are a side sleeper, and you have a too-firm mattress. The MyPillow topper keeps your shoulder and hip from pressing uncomfortably into the mattress.
The soft top layer is also helpful for back sleepers with back problems. It cushions your back to prevent painful pressure.
The bottom layer is firmer and is designed for support. It keeps your spine naturally aligned and keeps you from sinking too deep if your mattress is too soft.
Note that the MyPillow topper is not made with memory foam. So it doesn't have the deep body hug associated with memory foam toppers and mattresses.
On the upside, it doesn't get as hot as memory foam.
The MyPillow topper is available in all standard sizes and comes with a 10-year warranty.
Issues & Limitations
For a foam topper that's not made with memory foam, we think the MyPillow topper is a bit too expensive. We certainly don't recommend it if you are shopping on a budget.
Another issue is the heating. Though the topper doesn't get as hot as memory foam toppers, it can still get uncomfortably warm for hot sleepers.
Bottom Line
We'd love to see the price come down a bit. But overall, the MyPillow topper is still a great buy for anyone looking for a comfortable mattress topper.
4. Best Cooling: LUCID 2-Inch Ventilated Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper
If you are a hot sleeper, the best choice is to avoid memory foam. Get a latex or wool topper. But if you really love the soft feel of memory foam, get the Lucid 2″ ventilated gel memory foam topper.
It's not as cool as a latex topper, but it's much more comfortable for hot sleepers than most memory foam toppers.
Pros
- Sleeps cool.
- Excellent pressure relief.
- Affordable price.
Cons
- Some off-gassing when new.
Our Review
To make sure the topper stays cool, Lucid incorporates two cooling techniques in their 2″ topper.
The foam is infused with cooling gel. The gel absorbs body heat, helping you sleep cooler.
In addition, the foam is perforated to improve ventilation. This channels excess heat away from the mattress.
Usually, gel foam is not enough to keep the bed cool. But with the addition of ventilation, the Lucid topper manages to sleep fairly cool.
Remember to keep your expectations in check, however. This is not a latex topper. If you are very sensitive to heat, the topper may still feel a bit warm during summer.
The 2″ profile of the Lucid topper is perfect for softening a too-firm mattress without making it too plush. It provides great pressure relief for your shoulders and back while keeping your spine properly aligned.
If you need a plusher topper with a deeper hug, Lucid sells a 3″ version.
Issues & Limitations
Expect a slight chemical smell when you unbox the topper. This is normal for memory foam toppers and mattresses.
It's mild but can affect you if you are sensitive to odors. The smell goes away in a couple of days.
Bottom Line
A latex, bamboo, or wool topper is the best option for hot sleepers. But if you insist on memory foam, we recommend the Lucid 2″ ventilated and gel-infused memory foam topper.
5. Best for Stomach Sleepers: Pure Green 2″ 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper
Stomach sleepers need a firm or extra-firm sleeping surface for a comfortable sleeping experience. A too-soft mattress that causes your midsection to sink will put pressure on the spine and result in back problems.
The Pure Green natural latex topper firms up a soft or sagging mattress and improves support and spinal alignment.
Pros
- Great support and alignment.
- Ideal for soft and mildly sagging mattresses.
- 100% natural latex – healthier and eco-friendlier.
- Great for hot sleepers.
Cons
- Pricey.
- The topper is heavy and tedious to move.
- Mild latex smell when new.
Our Review
The Pure Green latex topper is extra-firm with an ILD rating of 44. That doesn't mean that you'll feel like you are sleeping on a plank of wood. It's firm without being rigid.
You'll still sink slightly into the topper, which ensures you don't experience pressure points on any part of your body.
The Pure Green topper is ideal for mattresses that feel too soft. We especially recommend it for stomach sleepers as well as heavier sleepers who'd like a more supportive mattress.
It can also help if your mattress is worn out and sags a bit in the middle. Note, however, that it will not help with a severely sagging mattress. The topper may seem fine at first, but it'll eventually sag in the middle.
One advantage of going for a natural latex topper like this one is the cooling performance. If most of the memory foam toppers or mattresses you've slept on leaving you hot and clammy, the Pure Green topper is the opposite.
Natural latex does not retain heat and sleeps cool throughout the year.
The Pure Green natural latex topper is available in all standard sizes. The 2″ thickness is the most popular. But you can also get the 1″ if your mattress is already fairly firm and you only need to firm it up slightly. There's also a 3″ option for sleepers who want a bit more pressure relief.
Issues & Limitations
Natural latex bedding is typically expensive, and the Pure Green topper is no different. It costs more than a standard memory foam topper.
Another sorta downside with latex toppers is their weight. The 2″ queen size topper weighs almost 35lbs. You'll need help lifting and moving it around.
Some people also don't like the natural rubber smell the Pure Green topper produces when new. If it bothers you, it'll disappear in a couple of days.
Bottom Line
Most people shopping for a mattress topper are looking for something to soften their mattress. But if you are a stomach sleeper, you need the opposite.
The Pure Green natural latex topper provides firm support and alignment, not to mention its excellent temperature regulation.
6. Best for Side Sleepers: Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Foam 4-inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper
As we've explained above, stomach sleepers need a firm surface, and a latex topper is perfect for that. What about side sleepers?
Unlike stomach sleepers who most need support, side sleepers need plenty of pressure relief under their shoulder and hip. Otherwise, you'll wake up sore.
The 4″ Sleep Innovations gel memory foam topper provides the best body-hugging pressure relief for side sleepers.
The extra-thick profile means even heavier sleepers will still enjoy superior body contouring.
Pros
- Excellent pressure relief – great for side sleepers.
- Gel memory foam helps with cooling.
- It comes with a washable cover.
- Great for side sleepers with shoulder or hip pain.
Cons
- May sleep hot for hot sleepers.
- Some off-gassing when new.
Our Review
The Sleep Innovations topper is essentially a mini-mattress. At 4″ thick, it's thicker than most mattress toppers you'll find in the market.
That's what makes it so good for side sleepers. Even if you weigh more than average, you'll sink snugly into the topper without hitting the firm mattress underneath.
The Sleep Innovations topper has two layers. The core is a 3″ layer of gel memory foam. It provides deep pressure relief and some support. The infused gel helps with cooling.
At the top of the memory, foam core is an inch thick layer of fiberfill. It essentially looks and feels like a pillow top topper. It's super plush and fluffy.
Unlike most toppers, the Sleep Innovations topper comes with a removable and washable cover. The cover secures the topper to your mattress. It can stretch to cover mattresses up to 18″ thick.
Note that the Sleep Innovations topper is available in two varieties. If you want an extra-soft sleeping experience, select the ultra-soft support option. If you want a bit more support, select the enhanced support option.
Issues & Limitations
The Sleep Innovations topper uses gel to absorb body heat. The memory foam core also has channels that improve airflow.
Despite this, many customers say they still felt a bit too warm when sleeping on the topper. That's likely because of the close body hug of the plush fiberfill top and memory foam core.
Another issue raised by customers is off-gassing. The topper gives off a fairly strong ‘new foam' smell when you unbox it, though it dissipates in a few days.
Bottom Line
A too-firm mattress can be brutal on your hips and shoulders if you are a side sleeper. It can even lead to back pain.
The 4″ Sleep Innovations gel memory foam topper is the best solution if you don't want to buy a new, more comfortable mattress.
7. Best Temperature Regulation: Sleep Number DUALTEMP™ INDIVIDUAL LAYER
If you sleep extra hot, we recommend an active cooling system like the Sleep Number Dual Temp.
It provides a much better cooling performance compared to passive systems such as gel or ventilated foam.
The Sleep Number Dual Temp uses heated or cooled air to regulate bed temperature. It's not just for folks who sleep hot; it's also great for those who sleep cold or live in a chilly climate.
Sleep Number sells the pad as an individual layer, so you can get two for each side of the bed if you and your partner have different sleeping preferences.
Pros
- Active temperature regulation.
- Customizable comfort for each side of the bed.
- Saves AC energy costs.
- It comes with remote control.
- Auto shut-off timer.
Cons
- Expensive.
- You can't select a specific temperature.
Our Review
Sleep Number Dual Temp consists of a pad with a hose stitched onto it. The hose leads to the main system that sits on the floor adjacent to the bed.
The main unit pumps cool or warm air through the hose and into the pad. The pad has small holes on the surface where the air comes out.
You use the included remote control to set your preferred comfort level. You can select from three cool levels and three warm levels.
According to the manufacturer, the Dual Temp pad can get up to 35% cooler or warmer than your bed.
An active cooling system like Dual Temp is great for those whom foam toppers, even those with gel or ventilated channels, still feel too warm. It's also great for those with hot flushes or night sweats.
The Dual Temp system can also help if you are on the other end of the spectrum. If your legs or body gets cold at night, the Dual Temp pad maintains a constant, comfortable temperature.
Note that Dual Temp is available as an individual layer. You can only buy a half queen, king, or Cal king.
This allows you to customize your bed if you sleep with your partner. You can order two Dual Temps, then each of you can set the temperature you prefer.
By the way, the remote comes with an auto shut-off timer that you can set in one-hour intervals up to nine hours.
The Sleep Number Dual Temp system comes with a 30-night trial period and a 1-year warranty.
Issues & Limitations
For one, the Dual Temp system is expensive. An individual layer costs about as much as a good quality memory foam mattress. Buying two for you and your partner will cost the same as a luxury hybrid mattress.
Depending on your budget, you may find it easier to just go with a natural latex topper.
For the price, there are a few features we would have liked to see. For instance, precise temperature control, which the slightly more expensive BedJet 3 offers, would have been nice.
We also love BedJet's biorhythm feature that allows you to set different temperatures for every hour of the night. In contrast, the only kind of control Dual Temp offers beyond temperature levels is a basic auto-off timer.
To compare Dual Temp with other cooling pads, including BedJet, read our reviews of the best cooling pads for 2021.
Bottom Line
The Sleep Number Dual Temp is more expensive than any foam or latex mattress pad. But for extra hot or cold sleepers, it's worth it.
8. Best Memory Foam: Tempur-Pedic ProForm Mattress Topper
Tempur-Pedic is the memory foam leader. Their memory foam mattresses, though pricey, outdo most other brands in comfort, support, cooling, and durability.
So if you are looking for the best memory foam topper, Tempur-Pedic is an obvious choice.
Their TEMPUR-ProForm Supreme 3″ topper provides a perfectly balanced medium-firm feel, with just the right amount of pressure relief and support for all kinds of sleepers.
Pros
- Medium-firm comfort – ideal for most types of sleepers.
- TEMPUR memory foam adapts to your pressure points.
- Good lumbar support – helps with back pain.
- Washable cover.
- Durable – comes with a 10-year warranty.
Cons
- Pricey.
- It can get a bit too warm.
Our Review
Tempur-Pedic uses the premium TEMPUR material they use in their high-end mattresses. TEMPUR is an exclusive memory foam formulation that provides superior body contouring and support.
The Tempur-Pedic ProForm topper is ideal for a too-soft mattress that needs more support or a too-firm mattress that needs a softer surface to relieve pressure.
It can also help with back pain.
Because of its medium-firm feel, the ProForm topper is ideal for most types of sleepers, including side, back, and some stomach sleepers.
The ProForm topper comes with a removable and washable cover, something you don't get with most toppers. This makes it easier to keep the topper clean and allergens-free.
With a 10-year warranty, we expect the Tempur-Pedic ProForm topper to last a long time.
Issues & Limitations
For hot sleepers, the Tempur-Pedic ProForm topper can sometimes feel a bit too warm. The TEMPUR memory foam, though superior to ordinary memory foam, still retains quite a bit of heat.
If you sleep hot, we recommend the medium + cooling option. It uses TEMPUR-ES memory foam and a special cooling cover.
Another issue with the Tempur-Pedic ProForm topper is the price. It costs 2-3 times the price of most memory foam toppers.
Bottom Line
Similar to the brand's mattresses, the Tempur-Pedic ProForm topper is more expensive than most other brands. But in return, you get a more comfortable sleeping experience, not to mention a longer-lasting topper.
Instead of buying a new topper every 2-4 years, why not get a premium one that lasts you eight years or more?
9. Best Organic: Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper
If you are not a big fan of synthetic bedding, a natural latex topper is your best option. If you prefer certified organic products, we recommend the Avocado Green organic latex topper.
It is, of course, pricier than memory foam toppers. But in return, you get a guaranteed chemical-free, long-lasting and comfortable 2″ topper.
Pros
- Organic.
- Two firmness options.
- Great for hot sleepers and night sweats.
- Organic cotton cover with organic wool quilting.
Cons
- Pricey.
Our Review
The Avocado Green organic topper is available in two firmness options: firm and plush.
Get the firm topper if your problem is an overly soft mattress, and you want to boost support. The firm option is also great for stomach sleepers.
Get the plush topper if your problem is an overly firm mattress, and you want better pressure point relief. The plush topper can also help with back pain.
Both comfort options have the same construction: a 2″ organic latex core and an organic cotton cover quilted with organic wool. The latex is GOLS organic certified while the wool and cotton cover carry GOTS certification.
Note: The cover has a zipper, meaning you can remove it. But do not machine wash or hand wash the cover or the latex core.
The Avocado Green organic topper is a great choice for hot sleepers. Latex, especially natural latex, does not retain heat like memory foam.
The wool and cotton cover also provides excellent breathability, which is good for those hot nights as well as night sweats. The organic wool is especially good at absorbing moisture.
If you tend to get a bit chilly some nights, the wool under the cover also acts as an insulator when it's cold, keeping you comfortably warm.
Issues & Limitations
If you are shopping for a budget mattress topper, the Avocado Green topper is probably not it. You could probably buy a good quality foam mattress for the price of the Queen size topper.
Another issue to note is that the topper is heavy. It's tedious to lift and set up on the bed, especially considering that latex is delicate and can rip if not handled properly.
Bottom Line
The price tag is high, but for an organic latex topper, with organic cotton and organic wool, it's fair.
10. Best for Heavy Sleepers: Latex Mattress Factory 3” Medium Natural Latex Mattress Topper
The 3” Latex Mattress Factory mattress topper provides the right combination of support and pressure relief for heavier sleepers weighing over 200lbs.
It doesn't bottom out like some memory foam toppers, nor does it get hot.
Pros
- Good support for heavier sleepers.
- Medium comfort feel that provides good pressure relief.
- Sleeps cool.
- 100% natural latex.
Cons
- Costs more than memory foam toppers.
Our Review
Memory foam toppers are plush and comfortable, but most don't provide the level of support heavier sleepers need.
Most people sink in too deep, which affects spinal alignment and can cause or worsen back pain.
That’s why we recommend a latex mattress topper for people with a bigger body. Latex, even softer latex, provides good support.
It hugs your body without bottoming out.
This 3” natural Dunlop latex topper from Latex Mattress Factory has a medium comfort feel that provides a great balance between soft pressure relief and firm support.
It is especially ideal for heavier sleepers who sleep on their side or back. If you are a stomach sleeper, you’ll need a firm latex topper. We recommend the 3” Pure Green firm latex topper.
You can also pick a topper from our reviews of the best firm mattress toppers.
Heavier sleepers tend to get hotter at night. This is another reason we highly recommend the Latex Mattress Factory topper.
Latex is naturally cool and breathable. It does not trap heat like memory foam, and allows body heat to escape.
If you currently sleep hot on your mattress, the Latex Mattress Factory topper will help.
Issues & Limitations
The only downside of the Latex Mattress Factory topper is the price. Natural latex toppers are 2-3 times more expensive than memory foam toppers.
On the upside, the Latex Mattress Factory topper sleeps cooler, it’s more supportive, and will last longer than a memory foam topper. It’s also 100% natural and more environmentally friendly.
Bottom Line
The Latex Mattress Factory natural latex topper is a great choice for heavier sleepers looking for a topper that will provide adequate support and pressure relief.
Avoid it if you are shopping on a budget or prefer the deep hug of memory foam.
11. Best For Back Pain: LUCID 2 Inch Zoned Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
The Lucid 2” zoned gel memory foam is designed to provide targeted support and pressure relief to your upper, middle, and lower body using zones of varying firmness.
The zoned design greatly improves sleeping posture and alignment, which can help reduce back pain.
Pros
- Improves sleeping posture.
- Pressure-relieving memory foam.
- Infused with cooling gel.
- Affordable.
Cons
- Not suitable for stomach and heavy sleepers.
Our Review
The Lucid gel memory foam topper has five zones. Each zone has a slightly different feel, designed to provide more support or hug your body more depending on which part of the body it’s under.
For instance, the zone right under your back is a bit firmer for support, while the zone under your shoulders is softer for pressure relief.
These zones align your body in a natural posture, ensuring your back is not under any pressure or strain. This can reduce back pain or even get rid of it if it was caused by an uncomfortable mattress.
The memory foam has a medium feel, which improves overall pressure relief particularly for side sleepers and back sleepers.
Cooling gel infused into the memory foam helps with temperature regulation.
For added cooling and breathability, we recommend getting a breathable cover for the topper since it doesn't come with one.
Issues & Limitations
The Lucid zoned gel memory foam topper is too soft for stomach sleepers. If you sleep on your stomach, you need a firmer sleeping surface to keep your back aligned. A soft topper like this one can worsen your back pain.
We also do not recommend the Lucid zoned topper for heavy sleepers weighing over 200lbs. You also need a firmer topper with more support. Get a latex topper instead.
Bottom Line
The Lucid zoned gel memory foam topper is a great choice for back pain sufferers looking for a supportive and pressure-relieving mattress topper.
Avoid it if you sleep on your stomach or weigh over 200lbs. The topper will not provide adequate support for you.
12. Best For Softening a Firm Mattress: Amazon Basics Down-Alternative Mattress Topper
The Amazon Basics down alternative mattress topper is perfect for softening a too-firm mattress without reducing support.
Pros
- Great for firm mattresses.
- Doesn't cause bottoming out.
- Sleeps cooler than memory foam.
- Machine washable.
Cons
- Not suitable for very firm mattresses – get a memory foam topper instead.
- Not ideal for heavier sleepers and some side sleepers.
Our Review
The AmazonBasics down alternative mattress topper is a good choice if you want to add a bit of softness to a too-firm mattress.
It can help if your new mattress is firmer than you like or your mattress has gotten firmer with age.
You won’t sink as deep as you would on a memory foam topper, so you’ll still get adequate support from your mattress.
The soft fiberfill prevents your pressure points (hips, shoulders, lower back, etc.) from digging into the mattress. It also improves overall pressure relief and sleeping posture.
The fill is contained in a breathable polyester shell. Baffle boxes sewn into the topper prevent the fiberfill from shifting around and help the topper maintain its loft.
The AmazonBasics microfiber topper is machine washable.
Issues & Limitations
Do not get the AmazonBasics down alternative topper if you want to add a lot of softness or a deep plush feel to your bed.
Get a memory foam topper instead.
We also don't recommend the AmazonBasics topper for heavier sleepers, particularly those who sleep on their side. It’s too thin to really hug your body and relieve pressure.
A 3” or 4” topper will be more comfortable.
Bottom Line
The AmazonBasics down alternative topper is a great choice for anyone looking for a topper that will add a bit of softness to their mattress without compromising support.
Avoid it if you want a topper you can sink into. Go with memory foam instead. It’s also the best choice for heavier folks and side sleepers who need extra pressure relief.
Mattress Topper Buying Guide
What Is a Mattress Topper and Why Should You Consider Getting One?
A mattress topper is a thin layer of foam, fiber, latex, or wool that you place on top of your mattress.
It’s the best way to improve the comfort of your mattress without buying a new one.
Depending on the firmness and type of mattress topper, it can make your mattress firmer (more support), softer (more pressure relief), or cooler.
If you have an old, sagging, and worn out mattress, it’s best if you buy a new one.
However, if you don't have the budget for a new good quality mattress right now, a mattress topper can extend the life of your current mattress.
A mattress topper can also help if you have a new mattress that turns out to be firmer, softer, or hotter than you expected.
It’s also the best choice if your mattress is still in a good condition but feels uncomfortable.
Benefits Of Using A Mattress Topper
Here are some reasons why you should consider buying a mattress topper.
- To soften a too-firm mattress. A soft or medium-firm mattress topper will improve pressure point relief and spinal alignment on an overly firm mattress.
- To firm up a too-soft mattress. A firm or medium-firm mattress topper will improve support and spinal alignment on an overly soft mattress.
- To reduce back pain. If your current mattress is causing or worsening back pain, a more supportive topper can help. Depending on how firm your current mattress is, get a soft or firm topper.
- To reduce hip and shoulder pain. An overly firm mattress can cause or worsen hip or shoulder pain for side sleepers. A soft memory foam mattress topper will provide better body contouring and pressure point relief.
- To reduce heating. If your memory foam mattress gets too hot at night, a latex topper will help you sleep cooler. If you are on a budget, get a ventilated gel memory foam topper. We recommend the Lucid topper that we've reviewed above. If you sleep extra hot, consider getting an active cooling mattress pad like the Sleep Number Dual Temp.
- To reduce motion transfer. Hybrid and spring mattresses can be too bouncy to the point where your partner's movements wake you up. Adding a foam topper will reduce motion transfer.
- To increase mattress loft. If you feel that your mattress is too low to the ground, maybe because of a low foundation, you can use a mattress topper to add loft and make it easier to get in and out of bed. Making the bed higher can also help you sleep warmer.
Mattress toppers are not just great for mattresses. You can use a 3″ or more topper on its own as a temporary mattress.
A mattress topper can also make a sleeper sofa or day bed more comfortable.
What To Look For In A Good Mattress Topper
Cooling Performance
Different types of mattress toppers have different cooling properties. If you are buying a mattress topper specifically for your heat-trapping mattress, it’s important that you get a topper that actually sleeps cool.
If you are buying a topper to soften or firm up your mattress, it’s still important that you buy a topper that sleeps cool. You don't want a topper that suddenly turns your bed into a sauna.
Memory foam toppers have the worst reputation when it comes to cooling. But there are some good ones.
- If you are a mild hot sleeper, a gel infused or swirl gel memory foam topper will feel cool. If it comes with a breathable cover, it’ll sleep even cooler.
- For those who sleep a bit warmer and don't want to spend too much money on a topper, we recommend a down alternative mattress topper. It doesn't trap as much heat as memory foam and it’s more breathable.
- For extra-hot sleepers who need all the cooling performance they can get, there are three types of toppers that will work: a natural down topper, a natural latex topper, or a natural wool topper.
Yes, natural materials sleep the coolest.
Here's what to consider when shopping for a mattress topper.
Materials
The first thing to decide is the type of mattress topper you want. Here are the most common varieties.
- Memory foam toppers – these are the most common and cheapest toppers. Memory foam toppers are great for softening a too-firm mattress. They are also the best for folks with back, shoulder, or hip pain. On the downside, most memory foam toppers can get a bit too warm.
- Latex toppers – if you don't like the feel of memory foam, try a latex topper. It can be synthetic, blended, or 100% natural latex topper. Natural/organic latex toppers are the best, though they are expensive. They sleep cool, provide good support, and last long.
- Wool toppers – a wool topper is another good choice if you want a natural topper. Wool toppers provide excellent pressure point relief and are great at temperature and moisture regulation. On the downside, natural wool toppers are pricey.
- Fiberfill toppers – if you want the soft feel of a wool topper at a lower price, try a fiberfill topper. It softens a firm mattress without making it overly plush. Note that fiberfill toppers can run hot, especially if you are a hot sleeper.
- Innerspring toppers – if you feel your mattress could do with a bit more bounciness and support, get a coil or spring topper.
Firmness
Once you know the type of topper you want, the next factor to consider is firmness. The best topper firmness depends on your comfort needs and the firmness of your current mattress.
Get a firm topper if:
- You sink too much in your current mattress, and you want more support.
- You are a stomach sleeper, and your current mattress is not providing adequate support.
Get a medium/medium-firm topper if:
- You want to make your mattress only slightly softer or firmer.
- You want a softer mattress without sinking in or a firmer mattress but with somebody contouring.
- You have back pain. A medium or medium-firm topper provides the best soft-firm balance for back problems.
Get a soft topper if:
- Your mattress feels too firm.
- You want more pressure point relief under your back, shoulders, or hips.
Thickness
Mattress toppers can be as thin as 1″ or as thick as 6″. Beyond 6″, you are essentially buying a mattress.
Generally, the thicker the topper, the softer and plusher it feels. So if you want a more pressure-relieving mattress topper, get one that's at least 3″ thick.
If you want firmer support, a 1″ or 2″ medium-firm or firm topper will do.
Note that a thicker topper will cost you significantly more. You'll find a price difference of $20-$50 between a 2″ and 3″ mattress topper from the same company.
So keep your budget in mind when selecting the best thickness.
Size
Mattress toppers come in the same standard sizes as mattresses. Just pick the size that corresponds to your mattress size.
Note that sometimes the topper may be slightly shorter or longer than the mattress. But this shouldn't affect comfort.
Tip: If your partner is satisfied with the current mattress, you can buy a twin XL topper and use it only on your side of the bed.
Cover
Most mattress toppers don't come with a cover. If you are concerned about stains or allergens getting onto the topper, look for one that comes with a cover.
Check if you can remove and wash the cover.
Mattress Toppers: FAQs
What is a mattress topper?
A mattress topper is a thin layer of foam, latex, wool, or fiber that you place on an existing mattress to make it more comfortable.
You can use a mattress topper to make your mattress firmer, softer, cooler, or just loftier.
What is the difference between a mattress pad and a mattress topper?
Sometimes, the terms mattress pad and topper are used interchangeably.
But traditionally, a mattress pad is thinner. It resembles a fluffy comforter. Most mattress pads even come with an elastic cover that you use to secure the pad to the mattress.
Most mattress pads contain wool, bamboo rayon, synthetic fiber, or down as the padding material.
Mattress toppers, on the other hand, are typically thicker, with most being 2-4 inches thick. Unlike a mattress pad that you secure to the mattress with a cover or elastic straps, a pad just sits on the mattress.
Most mattress pads are made with memory foam or latex.
Both mattress pads and mattress toppers do the same thing: they change how the mattress feels to make it more comfortable.
Mattress pads are almost always used to soften a mattress. Mattress toppers can be used to soften or firm up a mattress.
How to keep mattress topper from sliding
Here are some things you can use to keep a mattress topper from sliding. You can buy most of them online or at a local store.
- Sheet suspenders or holder straps.
- Slip-resistant pad like this one from Gorilla Grip. Place the pad under your mattress topper.
- Duct tape the topper to the mattress. Apply the tape to the corners of the topper.
- Safety pins. Attach the topper to the mattress using at least five pins on each side.
How to clean a mattress topper
Most mattress toppers are not washable. Only fiberfill toppers can be machine washed.
Some mattress toppers come with a removable cover that you can wash.
If your topper is not washable and doesn't have a washable cover, the only way to clean it is by spot cleaning. Use mild detergent and cold water to wipe off dirt spots and stains.
What’s the best mattress topper for different sleeping styles?
Back sleepers need a good balance between firm support and soft pressure relief. We recommend a medium or medium firm memory foam or latex topper.
A fiber or wool topper is also a good choice for softening a firm mattress while maintaining support.
Stomach sleepers need a firm sleeping surface. We recommend a firm latex topper or a thin down alternative topper.
Side sleepers need lots of pressure relief and a dep hug. We recommend a soft or medium memory foam topper that 2-4 inches thick.
Will a mattress topper help with back and hip pain?
The right topper can reduce body aches on the back, hips, shoulders and other joints.
For back pain, get a medium firm topper that supports your back while relieving pressure. For hip pain, get a softer topper that relieves pressure on your hips.
Gel memory foam vs. memory foam mattress topper
A traditional memory foam topper can get a bit too warm. That’s because the memory foam traps body heat and doesn't release it.
Gel memory foam contains cooling that absorbs body heat to help you sleep cooler. However, gel memory foam toppers have a limited cooling effect, especially for people who sleep extra hot.
If you get really hot at night, we recommend a topper made with natural materials like wool, latex, or down.
Should you put a mattress topper under or on top of a mattress protector?
Place the mattress topper under the mattress protector. That way, the mattress protector protects both your mattress topper and mattress.
It also helps keep the mattress topper from shifting about on the mattress.
Affiliate Disclosure
Affiliate Disclosure: I may earn a small commission (at no cost to you) if you purchase a mattress after clicking a referral link or using a coupon code on this site. That said, all content and opinions on this site are my own and are NOT affected by these payments.
This site participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
*Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
